The Soul’s Journey After Death

Introduction and general message
His Holiness Pope Shenouda III responds to circulated ideas about what happens to the soul after death, warning against relying on late mêmêrs full of myths and contradictions in forming doctrine. The gist of the lecture is a call to distinguish between authentic Christian tradition and popular teachings or texts that are historically or theologically unverified.

Main points

1. Many mêmêrs (narrative texts) attributed to fathers or ancient visions come from relatively late manuscripts (like the seventeenth century) and we must not base church doctrines on them.
2. Such texts contain myths and theological contradictions—like stories of a soul wandering the earth for days, then being presented before God, then lowered to hell, then ascending on the fortieth day—and must be rejected when they contradict Scripture and the fathers’ teachings.
3. Remembrances on the third day, the seventh day, the fortieth, or the annual commemoration are customs and ways to remember death and warn against negligence, not texts for new doctrine or cosmic processes as some mêmêrs relate.
4. The soul after death does not know everything as if it were a god; complete knowledge belongs to God alone. A soul may be granted certain news by God, but it is not aware of every detail on earth.
5. Ideas like human souls entering animals or multiple incarnations (reincarnation) have no support in Scripture nor in the Church Fathers’ tradition; they are theologically and logically wrong.
6. Children’s talents (prodigies) are not evidence of a previous life; matters are explained by heredity, environment, or a gift from God, not by the entrance of a former soul.
7. Some popular rites (sprinkling water on the deceased’s belongings, praying at the place of death, declarations to expel evil spirits) are exaggerated or lack theological support; the correct purpose of prayer for the dead is remembrance, intercession, and asking God for mercy.
8. Psychological and physical matters like gender identity differences are medically explained (hormonal imbalance or physiological structure) and have no relation to theories of soul return.

Spiritual and educational dimension (from a Coptic Orthodox faith perspective)

• A call to ground doctrine on the Holy Scripture and the teachings of the Church Fathers, not on late stories or myths.
• Encouragement to constant remembrance of death as a means to repentance and sanctification, not as mere magical rites.
• Directing spiritual care for the departed through proper prayers and remembrance, relying on theological reason and spiritual discernment.
• Rejecting the mixing of faith with popular non-Christian ideas; preserving the purity of doctrine and apostolic tradition.

For better translation support, please contact the center.