Responding to the father’s thoughts When the poor man
In this lecture, His Holiness Pope Shenouda III discusses certain theological errors found in writings about the Holy Spirit, Pentecost, and Baptism, addressing them with precise Orthodox reasoning.
🔹 1. The Meaning of the Descent of the Holy Spirit
His Holiness clarifies that Pentecost is the descent of the Holy Spirit upon the disciples to grant them power for ministry and preaching — not a union between the divine and human natures, as some wrongly claimed. Such an idea confuses the divinity of Christ with humanity.
🔹 2. Distinguishing Christ’s Divinity from Humanity
He stresses that the gravest theological error is either lowering Christ to human level or raising humans to Christ’s divine level — both deny the essential difference between Creator and creation. Christ alone is the incarnate God; receiving the Holy Spirit does not make one divine.
🔹 3. Baptism and the New Birth
He explains that new birth in baptism does not mean being literally born from Christ’s “flesh and bones,” but rather being spiritually renewed by grace — bearing the image of God in righteousness and holiness, not by essence but by grace.
🔹 4. Refuting the Idea of Pantheism (Union of Being)
His Holiness warns against the confusion between the physical body of Christ, born of the Virgin, crucified, and ascended, and the Church as His spiritual body. The Church is His mystical body by faith, not His divine essence. Mixing the two leads to the heresy of Pantheism, which all the Church Fathers rejected.
🔹 5. Errors in Certain Church Concepts
He also rejects the idea that interpreting Scripture is equal to divine inspiration, and the claim that there are “more than seven sacraments.” Every consecration in the Church operates through the Holy Chrism, not through new sacraments.
🔹 6. Defense of Orthodox Faith
Finally, he teaches that while the Holy Spirit dwells within believers to sanctify and strengthen them, He does not transform human nature into divine nature. Humanity remains free and capable of sin and repentance, but God alone is holy by nature.
This lecture shows Pope Shenouda’s deep Orthodox theology and his vigilant defense of the true faith against any deviation from sound Christian doctrine.
“For better translation support, please contact the center.”



