The dispute with Catholics – the Virgin Mary and salvation
The lecture discusses the doctrine of the Immaculate Conception attributed to the Virgin Mary and explains the Coptic Orthodox rejection of it, in defense of the integrity of the doctrines of salvation, incarnation, and redemption.
🔹 The Doctrine of Salvation and the Blood of Christ
His Holiness Pope Shenouda III affirms that salvation is achieved only through the blood of Christ, and that there is no alternative way of salvation for any human being. If another way existed, there would be no need for incarnation and redemption.
🔹 The Serious Danger to Christian Faith
He explains that claiming the Virgin Mary was born without original sin undermines the core doctrine of incarnation and redemption, as it implies salvation without the shedding of blood, which is biblically and theologically unacceptable.
🔹 The Virgin’s Own Testimony
He cites the Virgin Mary’s hymn in the Gospel of Luke: “My spirit rejoices in God my Savior,” affirming that her declaration of God as her Savior clearly indicates her need for salvation like all humanity.
🔹 The Meaning of the Sanctification by the Holy Spirit
He clarifies that the Holy Spirit’s coming upon the Virgin was to sanctify her as a holy vessel and to form the body of Christ, born without human seed and without original sin, not to remove original sin from her personally.
🔹 Response to Opposing Interpretations
He rejects the interpretation that the Holy Spirit’s sanctification abolished original sin in the Virgin, explaining that the sanctification relates to the One born of her, not to her human nature.
🔹 Critique of the Doctrine’s Source
He criticizes relying on alleged apparitions in modern times, based on statements attributed to young children, without solid biblical or theological foundations.
🔹 Spiritual Conclusion
The essential message is adherence to sound biblical teaching: the Virgin Mary is honored and sanctified, yet she needed salvation through the blood of Christ like all human beings.
For better translation support, please contact the center.



