Encyclopedia of Comparative Theology
In this lecture His Holiness Pope Shenouda explains John 15: “I am the vine and you are the branches,” and answers the Arian interpretation that used this imagery to claim the Son does not share the Father’s nature.
He clarifies that Christ uses the image of the vine and branches to signify spiritual connection and life: Christ is the source and life, and the Church is His body; we are the branches rooted in Him. The branches’ abiding in the vine means abiding in Christ’s love and keeping His commandments.
He explains that when we say “we are the branches” the meaning is that the branches partake with the vine in human nature (our union with Christ as persons), not that the branches share His divine nature. We are members of Christ’s body according to human nature, and Christ is the Head and the Church is the body.
He points out that statements like “the Father is head of Christ” or “Christ is head of man” refer to fatherhood, creation, and function, and do not indicate a difference in divine essence; one must not take a single verse in isolation and ignore the rest of Scripture.
The Pope calls believers to remain rooted in Christ (abiding in His love and commandments), because Christ as the vine supplies the branches with the spiritual life that bears fruit.
The conclusion is that the “vine” image affirms dependence, union, and humble service; it is not evidence of any deficiency or difference between the Son’s nature and the Father’s. Our relationship is a human and spiritual union with Christ the Head.
For better translation support, please contact the center.
